The Efficacy of Evidence-Based Practice Training in
Enhancing Decision-Making Competency Utilizing Fishbone Diagrams Among Nurse
Managers at Hospital B Bandung
Angela Lalaa,1*, Wilhelmus
Harry Susilob,2, Tutianyb,3�
aRumah
Sakit Santo Borromeus, Jawa Barat, Indonesia
bSekolah
Tinggi Ilmu Kesehatan Sint Carolus, Jakarta, Indonesia
![]()
Received: 13-06-2024 �������������������� ������������� Accepted: 20-06-2024 �������������������� ��������������Published: 28-06-2024�����
ABSTRACT
The nurse manager is
crucial in overseeing and directing nursing services to accomplish
organizational objectives effectively. Nurse managers must possess the skill of
evidence-based decision-making. This reseacrh aims to determine the efficacy of
evidence-based practice training in enhancing decision-making skills among
nurse managers at Hospital B Bandung, specifically through utilizing the
Fishbone Diagram. This study employs quantitative research methodologies utilizing
a pre-experimental design, specifically a one-group pre-post design. The
research sample comprised 62 nurse managers, including 28 section heads, deputy
section heads, coordinators, and 34 CCMs. These individuals received
evidence-based practice decision-making training interventions involving
fishbone diagrams and post-training intervention. The data analysis method
employs the Wilcoxon bivariate test and the multivariate ordinal logistic
regression test. The intervention yielded statistically significant
improvements in decision-making practices, knowledge, attitudes, and skills.
The p-value for these changes was 0.000 (p < 0.05), indicating a high
confidence level in the results. This study suggests that providing
evidence-based practice training to hospital nurse managers is necessary to
enhance their decision-making skills. This can be achieved by utilizing
fishbone diagrams or other similar tools.
Keywords: Fishbone Diagram, Competency, Evidence-Based
Practice, Training, Nurse Manager, Decision-Making.
![]()
Coresponden: Angela Lala
Email: [email protected]
INTRODUCTION
Nursing services
are a type of professional service essential to the entire healthcare
provision. The provision of nursing services is a crucial factor in attaining
the objectives of a hospital. The topic pertains to nurses' leadership in
nursing services and global needs. It emphasizes the need for professional
management to effectively address and adapt to any changes that may arise (Umalihayati et al., 2023). The nurse
manager oversees and directs nursing services to meet the company's goals
effectively. Nurse managers are nurses responsible for coordinating all aspects
of nursing care, whether on an individual, family, or community level. The
management functions encompass planning, organizing, staffing, leading, and
supervising a workforce (Marquis & Huston, 2015). Nurse managers
must possess the competency of decision-making. Decision-making is choosing
options or courses of action based on specific criteria (Big Dictionary of
Science).
(Jankelov� et al., 2021) Defines
decision-making as a systematic process that involves analyzing a situation,
collecting factual information, carefully evaluating available choices, and
taking action based on calculated assessments to determine the most suitable
course of action. Proficient leadership skills are necessary for prompt
decision-making, considering immediate and long-term consequences. Nurse
managers' participation in decision-making profoundly influences nurses'
attitudes and beliefs, as they provide guidance and inspiration to help them
achieve organizational and professional objectives. This involvement is crucial
for delivering effective and efficient healthcare and facilitating future
professional growth and advancement, as required (Pishgooie et al., 2019); the Republic
of Indonesia Law No. 28 of 2014 concerning Copyright, n.d.).
Evidence-based
management (EBMgt) uses high-quality Evidence from diverse sources to inform
decision-making, which managers now consider essential. Within this context,
evidence-based management has been suggested to promote a stronger dependence
on data when making decisions (Briner et al., 2009). When employing
the EBMgt methodology, managers must ascertain, gather, or activate Evidence,
cooperate with other stakeholders, and subsequently integrate it into their
decision-making process (Moussata, 2017). Evidence-Based
Practice (EBP) is a systematic approach that enables healthcare professionals
to stay current and access the most recent information. This knowledge is a
foundation for making effective and efficient clinical decisions, ultimately
leading to optimal patient care (McNee, 2020). The successful
execution of Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) relies on sufficient resources. The
presence of sufficient human resources (HR) can facilitate the adoption of
evidence-based practices (EBP), including factors such as educational
qualifications, EBP-specific training, and other variables that can influence
EBP implementation, such as organizational culture and organizational
preparedness (Fonseca, 2023). Organizations
must implement educational programs focused on evidence-based practice (EBP) to
enhance knowledge, skills, attitudes, and self-confidence in utilizing research
findings in nursing care (Hidayat et al., 2019).
EBP
implementation is only universal across some hospitals. According to (Koota et al., 2021), a limited
number of nurses possess the necessary skills to implement evidence-based
practice (EBP) effectively. Research conducted by (Oktiayuliandri, 2015) indicates that
the adoption of evidence-based practice (EBP) has been implemented at RSUP Dr.
M. Djamil Padang since 2012. However, its effectiveness has yet to reach its
full potential. The low implementation of evidence-based practice (EBP) can be
attributed to several problems, including uniformity in nurse education,
inadequate knowledge among nurses, resistance to engaging with academic
journals and research, and limited understanding of research methodologies.
According to a study conducted by (Saunders & Vehvil�inen-Julkunen, 2016), the readiness
of nurses to implement evidence-based practice (EBP) is influenced by factors
such as their level of Education, knowledge of EBP, previous experience with
EBP, age, and years of work experience. The study also suggests that providing
training and guidance on EBP can enhance nurses' knowledge in this area.
Another hindering issue is the absence of assistance from the nurse manager in
adopting evidence-based practice in the room. Nurse managers are crucial in
fostering evidence-based practice (EBP) and must possess both practice and
leadership abilities. Nurse managers ' surveys on adopting evidence-based
practice (EBP) yielded inferior outcomes (Melnyk et al., 2008). (Clarke et al., 2021) also conveyed a
similar sentiment that adopting evidence-based practice (EBP) among nurses is
still significantly limited, with many nurse managers opting for a passive
approach towards its implementation (Wilkinson et al., 2011). The main
obstacles to implementing evidence-based practice (EBP) in 2018 are
insufficient resources, inadequate training in research methodologies, absence
of mentoring, lack of support from hospital administration, lack of enthusiasm
in implementing EBP findings, and limited time available to implement EBP in
the work environment. Musdalifa Kendeng et al. (2022) identified multiple
hurdles and impediments encountered by nurse managers throughout the
implementation of evidence-based practice (EBP). The absence of assistance from
management, insufficient resources and competencies in evidence-based practice
(EBP), and the nurse manager's leadership approach.
A fishbone
diagram, or an Ishikawa diagram or cause-effect analysis, is commonly employed
in decision-making. It is a reactive risk management technique that involves
identifying potential sources of a problem and determining its root cause
through brainstorming sessions. Identifying the underlying source of the
problem is expected to facilitate the implementation of necessary measures and
corrective actions. Nurse managers frequently use fishbone diagrams for problem
analysis during decision-making (Sudjiati et al., 2021).
One strategy to
address the limited adoption of evidence-based practices (EBP) is to provide
training. Training is a deliberate endeavor aimed at enhancing and cultivating
the attitudes, behavior, abilities, and knowledge of personnel in alignment
with the objectives and preferences of an institution or organization. Training
is a purposeful and systematic activity to acquire skills and information in a
particular profession. It enhances work effectiveness and efficiency (Iswan, 2021). (Alatawi et al., 2020) asserts that
training and Education are crucial in enhancing nurses' knowledge and skills in
utilizing evidence-based procedures.
According to the
observed phenomena, the facts indicate that nurse managers at Hospital B
Bandung lack sufficient knowledge and skills in applying evidence-based
practice (EBP) when making decisions using fishbone diagrams. Furthermore,
specific training has yet to be conducted on this matter. Researchers are
interested in thoroughly analyzing the impact of Evidence-Based Practice (EBP)
training in enhancing decision-making competency among nurse managers at
Hospital B Bandung, specifically through the use of fishbone diagrams, by
conducting EBP training sessions for decision-making, utilizing fishbone
diagrams, and evaluating the impact of the training on the knowledge and
abilities of nurse managers. This reserach aims to analyze the factors that affect village
financial management, both from internal and external factors. The benefits of
this study are to provide a deeper understanding of effective and efficient
village financial management, as well as provide recommendations for increasing
the capacity of financial management at the village level.
METHOD
This study employs a quantitative research approach
with a quasi-experimental design known as a one-group pretest-post-test design.
This design involves conducting an initial test (pretest) before administering
the treatment, followed by a final test (posttest) after the treatment has been
given. This research method was conducted (Rustika, 2013) in which a
single group was given a specific treatment and observed before and after the
treatment. The study was conducted at RS B Bandung from June to August 2023.
The research was conducted following the acquisition of approval from the
Director of Hospital B and ethical clearance from the STIK Sint Carolus
Research and Development Ethics Committee (No.079/KEPPKSTIKSC/VI/2023).
The sampling technique used is purposive sampling, where researchers
select samples based on certain criteria that are considered relevant to the
research objectives. The sample for this study comprised 62 nurse
managers, including 28 section heads/deputy section heads/coordinators and 34
CCMs. The study included nurses who held positions as head of section, deputy
head of section, Coordinator, and CCM/Clinical Care Manager at Hospital B
Bandung and who got a decision letter before the research was conducted. The
data gathering was conducted between June and August of 2023. Researchers
adhered to research ethical norms during the study to uphold research ethics.
The data collection tool employs a questionnaire
incorporating evidence-based practice in decision-making and decision-making
abilities utilizing fishbone diagrams. The research employed the Evidence-Based
Practice Questionnaire (EBPQ), first designed by (Upton Upton, 2006) and
subsequently adapted into an Indonesian form by Fajarini, 2020). The researcher
further changed the questionnaire to suit the specific requirements of the
current study. This questionnaire includes a knowledge scale with ten
statements, an attitude scale with four statements, and a practice/skills scale
with ten statements. Additionally, there is a decision-making skills
questionnaire with 16 statements, rated from 1 to 10, ranging from bad to very
good. The statements in the decision-making skills questionnaire have been
adapted from existing literature to meet current research requirements. The
questionnaire's validity was assessed in a hospital of the same category as the
research site, specifically S-type Hospital B in Jakarta. A total of 30
respondents were selected based on the research criteria. After conducting
tests to assess the validity of the questionnaire, it was determined to be both
valid and reliable. Data analysis techniques used univariate analysis, bivariate analysis,
and multivariate analysis.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Univariate Analysis
Table 1. Characteristics of Respondents
at Hospital B Bandung, Categorized
By Sex, Age, Education, Length Of Work,
Position, and Tenure
|
Variable |
Category |
Frequency |
Percentage (%) |
|
|
1 |
Sex |
- Male - Female |
7 55 |
11.3 88.7 |
|
2 |
Age |
- 20 � 40 yo - >40 � 56 yo |
31 31 |
50.0 50.0 |
|
3 |
Education |
- Associate/Diploma - Bachelor |
14 48 |
22.6 77.4 |
|
4 |
Length of Work |
- < 15 years - > 15 years |
27 35 |
43.5 56.5 |
|
5 |
Position |
- CCM/ PPB - Division Head/Deputy Division Head/Coordinator |
34 28 |
54.8 45.2 |
|
6 |
Tenure |
- < 5 years - > 5 years |
48 14 |
77.4 22.6 |
|
|
Total |
|
62 |
100 |
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 1 demonstrates that the
research sample mainly consisted of female nurse managers, with 55 individuals
(88.7%). In comparison, the remaining seven individuals (11.3%) were male.
There are 31 nurse managers between the ages of 22-40 and 31 nurse managers
over 40, making up 50.0% of the total. Out of the nurse managers, 77.4% possess
an undergraduate educational level, which amounts to 48 individuals. The
remaining nurse managers hold diploma degrees. More than half (56.5%) of nurse
managers had a length of service above 15 years, whereas only 43.5% had shorter
than 15 years. Of the total nurse managers, 34 individuals held the post of
CCM, accounting for 54.8% of the group. The remaining 45.2% were Head of
Division, Deputy Head of Division, or Coordinator. Most nurse managers (77.4%)
had a length of office that was less than or equal to 5 years.
Table 2.
Description of The Knowledge Related to Decision-Making based on Evidence
Based Practice (X1) in the
Pretest and Posttest (n=62)
|
No |
Variable |
Pretest |
Posttest |
||
|
Frequency |
% |
Frequency |
% |
||
|
Knowledge: - Poor (score:10-40) - Moderate (score 41-71) - Good (score 72-100) |
33 28 3 |
53.2 41.9 4.8 |
- 20 42 |
- 32.3 67.7 |
|
|
|
Total |
62 |
100 |
62 |
100 |
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 2 indicates that, out of
the 62 nurse manager respondents, 33 individuals (53.2%) reported a deficiency
in their understanding of utilizing evidence-based practice in decision-making,
whereas 28 individuals (41.9%) considered their knowledge adequate. Three
individuals (4.8%) saw it as excellent. Of the 62 nurse manager respondents, 20
individuals (32.3%) reported having adequate knowledge of utilizing
evidence-based practice in decision-making, whereas 42 individuals (67.7%)
expressed proficiency in this area.
Table 3.
Description of the Attitudes Towards Decision-Making Based on
Evidence-Based Practice (X1)
in the Pretest and Posttest (n=62)
|
No |
Variable |
Pretest |
Posttest |
||
|
Frequency |
% |
Frequency |
% |
||
|
3. |
Attitudes: -
Poor
(score:4-16) -
Moderate
(score 17-29) -
Good
(score 30-40) |
34 27 1 |
54.8 43.5 1.6 |
- 26 36 |
- 41.9 58.1 |
|
|
Total |
62 |
100 |
62 |
100 |
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 3 indicates that, out of
the 62 nurse manager participants in the pretest, 34 individuals (54.8%)
reported a deficiency in their inclination towards utilizing evidence-based
practice in decision-making, whereas 27 individuals (43.5%) deemed it adequate.
One person (1.6%) considered it to be satisfactory. Of the 62 nurse manager
responses, 26 (41.9%) reported utilizing evidence-based practice in
decision-making adequately, whereas 36 (58.1%) reported being good.
Table 4.
Description of Decision-Making Skills Based on Evidence-Based
Practice Using Fishbone Diagram (Y) in
the Pretest Posttest (n=62)
|
No |
Variable |
Pretest |
Posttest |
||
|
Frequency |
% |
Frequency |
% |
||
|
4. |
Decision-Making
Skills - Insufficient (score:16-64) - Satisfactory (score 65-113) - Excellent (score 114-160) |
9 50 3 |
14.5 80.6 4.8 |
37 25 |
59.7 40.3 |
|
|
Total |
62 |
100 |
62 |
100 |
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
Table 4 indicates that out of the 62 nurse
manager respondents in the pretest, nine individuals (14.5%) reported being
inadequate in utilizing fishbone diagrams to implement evidence-based practice
decision-making abilities, 50 individuals (80.6%) reported being proficient,
and three individuals (4.8%) reported being very skilled. Of the 62 nurse
management responses, 37 (59.7%) reported proficient decision-making abilities
utilizing evidence-based practice using fishbone diagrams. In contrast, 25
individuals (40.3%) reported being highly skilled.
As per Indonesian Law No.36 of 2014, competency
for health workers refers to their capacity to perform their duties
effectively, which is determined by their knowledge, skills, and professional
attitudes. Government rule No. 101 of 2000 states that civil servants must
acquire the specific information and behavioral attitudes necessary for their
roles and responsibilities. However, as per (Wibowo, 2016), competency refers to the capacity to effectively
perform a job or task, utilizing the necessary skills, knowledge, and work
attitudes demanded by the job.
Bivariate Analysis
Table 5. Wilcoxon Test Results for the
Variable of Decision-Making Practices
�Based on Evidence-Based Practice (X1)
Before and After Intervention
|
Variable |
N Negative
Ranks |
N Positive
Ranks |
N Ties Rank |
Mean
Positive Ranks |
The sum
of Positive Ranks |
Sig P
Value Wilcoxon |
|
Decision-Making Practices Based on EBP (X1) |
1 |
50 |
11 |
26.1 |
1309,50 |
0,000 |
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
Table 5 demonstrates that the
t-statistic yields a significant value of 0.000, less than 0.05. This indicates
a significant change in decision-making using evidence-based practice after the
intervention.
Table 6. Wilcoxon Test Results for the Variableof
Decision-Making Knowledge
Based on Evidence-Based Practice (X1)
Before and After Intervention
|
Variable |
N Negative
Ranks |
N Positive
Ranks |
N Ties
Rank |
Mean
Positive Ranks |
The sum
of Positive Ranks |
Sig P
Value Wilcoxon |
|
Decision-Making Knowledge Based on EBP (X1) |
0 |
52 |
10 |
26.50 |
1378.0 |
0,000 |
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
Table 6 indicates that the t statistical results
yielded a significant value of 0.000 <0.05, indicating a substantial
alteration in decision-making knowledge utilizing evidence-based practice
following the intervention.
Table 7.
Wilcoxon Test Results for the Variable of Decision-Making Attitudes based on
Evidence-Based Practice (X1) Before and After Intervention
|
Variable |
N Negative Ranks |
N Positive Ranks |
N Ties Rank |
Mean Positive Ranks |
The sum of Positive Ranks |
Sig P Value Wilcoxon |
|
Decision-Making Attitudes based on EBP (X1) |
0 |
44 |
18 |
22.50 |
990.0 |
0,000 |
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
Table 7 displays the findings of t statistics,
which yielded a significant value of 0.000 <0.05. This indicates a
noteworthy alteration in decision-making attitudes towards evidence-based
practice following the intervention.
Table 8. Wilcoxon Test Results for the
Variable of Decision-Making Skills using Fishbone Diagram (Y) Based on
Evidence-Based Practice Before and After Intervention
|
Variable |
N Negative
Ranks |
N Positive
Ranks |
N Ties
Rank |
Mean
Positive Ranks |
The
sum of Positive Ranks |
Sig
P Value Wilcoxon |
|
Decision-Making Skills Based using Fishbone Diagram (Y) on EBP |
2 |
28 |
32 |
15.68 |
439.0 |
0,000 |
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 8 indicates that the t
statistical results yielded a significant value of 0.000 <0.05, indicating a
noteworthy alteration in decision-making abilities influenced by evidence-based
practice employing fishbone diagrams following the intervention. Therefore,
offering training in evidence-based practice has been demonstrated to
effectively enhance decision-making abilities rooted in evidence-based
practice, utilizing the fishbone diagram. Most participants performed well,
while a small fraction excelled on the pretest. Following the administration of
the intervention, the majority of the categories remained at a satisfactory
level, with a notable rise observed in the excellent category. The findings of
this study are corroborated by the research conducted by (Alatawi et al., 2020), which asserts that training and Education play a
crucial role in enhancing knowledge and skills through evidence-based
techniques.
Multivariate Analysis
Fit Model Feasibility Test
Table 9. Fit Model Feasibility Test of
Decision-Making Competency
using Fishbone Diagram based on
Evidence-Based Practice
|
|
-2 Log Likelihood |
Chi-Square |
df |
Sig. |
|
Intercept Only |
64.098 |
|
|
|
|
Final |
50.869 |
13.229 |
9 |
.153 |
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
Table 9 displays the suitability of the model's
fit on the dependent variable of decision-making competence using fishbone
diagrams grounded in evidence-based practice. After the training intervention
on applying evidence-based practice in decision-making using fishbone diagrams,
there was a decrease of -2 log probability from 64,098 to 50,869. Based on
statistical analysis, it can be inferred that the model incorporating the
independent variable of Evidence-Based Practice Training in Decision Making Using
Fishbone Diagrams yields higher accuracy in predicting improved decision-making
competence among nurse managers, as indicated by a p-value greater than 0.005.
Overall Model Test
Table 10. Overall Model Test of
Decision-Making Competency
�Using Fishbone Diagram Based on Evidence-Based
Practice
|
|
Chi-Square |
df |
Sig. |
|
Pearson |
32.736 |
30 |
.334 |
|
Deviance |
37.654 |
30 |
.159 |
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 10 displays the level of
agreement between the dependent variable of decision-making competence and a
fishbone diagram grounded in evidence-based practice. The Chi-Square value was
greater than 0.05, indicating that the probability value for the intervention
was statistically significant. The evidence-based practice training
intervention utilizes a research model that uses a fishbone diagram to predict
decision-making competence based on evidence-based practice. This prediction
uses a significance level (p-value) greater than 0.05.
Pseudo R-Square Test
Table 11. Pseudo R-Square Test on the
Intervention Group of Evidence-
Based Practice Training for Decision-Making
Competence Using Fishbone Diagram
|
.192 |
|
|
Negelkerke |
.260 |
|
McFadden |
.158 |
���������������������������������������������������
Source: 2023 Primary Research Data
The results of testing the impact of enhancing
decision-making competence using a fishbone diagram grounded on evidence-based
practice are presented in Table 11. The Pseudo R-squared value, precisely the
Cox and Snell value, is 0.192. This indicates that 19.2% of the variation in
the independent variable (Evidence-Based Practice Training) can be explained by
the dependent variable (Increasing Decision-Making Competency Using Fishbone
Diagrams). The remaining 80.8% is attributed to other variables not included in
the model. According to the researcher's assumptions, the Cox and Snell
determination test yielded findings of 19.2%, indicating that the independent
variable can only have a 19.2% impact on the dependent variable. In order to
enhance the value of research, it is imperative to incorporate additional
variables that can potentially impact the improvement of decision-making skills
among nurse managers. These variables may include participant motivation,
organizational support, predisposition to change, time and active
participation, utilization of training materials, availability of additional
resources, and team involvement. Based on evidence-based practice, the fishbone
diagram can be utilized for this purpose (Tazebew et al., 2023). Management support, support structures,
organizational and professional ideals, and disparities in health policies and
hospital settings all impact decision-making skills. The study revealed that
nurse managers who got management help demonstrated significantly higher
decision-making participation levels than those who did not receive such
support.
Parameter Estimate Test
Table 12. Parameter Estimate Test for
Independent Variables on Decision-Making
Competence Using Fishbone Diagram in
Evidence-Based Practice Training Intervention
|
Parameter
Estimates |
||||||||
|
Estimate |
Std.
Error |
Wald |
df |
Sig. |
95%
Confidence Interval |
|||
|
Lower
Bound |
Upper
Bound |
|||||||
|
Threshold |
Decision-Making Fish bone Post = 2] |
-1.035 |
.840 |
1.518 |
1 |
218 |
-2,681 |
.612 |
|
Location |
[Sex=1] |
.443 |
997 |
.197 |
1 |
.657 |
-1.511 |
2.397 |
|
[Sex=2] |
0 |
- |
- |
0 |
. |
|||
|
[Age=1] |
1.300 |
1.378 |
.890 |
1 |
345 |
-1.401 |
4.000 |
|
|
[Age=2] |
0 |
0 |
. |
|||||
|
[Education =]] |
-475 |
.798 |
354 |
1 |
.552 |
-2.038 |
1.089 |
|
|
[Education=2] |
0 |
. |
. |
0 |
. |
|||
|
[Length of Work=1] |
-1.844 |
1,427 |
1.671 |
1 |
196 |
-4.641 |
952 |
|
|
[Length of Work=2] |
0 |
0 |
||||||
|
[Position=1] |
-276 |
.719 |
.147 |
1 |
.702 |
-1.685 |
1.134 |
|
|
[Position=2] |
0 |
0 |
||||||
|
[Tenure=1] |
-215 |
.770 |
.078 |
1 |
.780 |
-1.723 |
1.293 |
|
|
[Tenure=2] |
0 |
0 |
. |
|||||
|
[Practice Post=2] |
-.859 |
906 |
.900 |
1 |
343 |
-2.634 |
.916 |
|
|
[Practice Post=3] |
0 |
0 |
||||||
|
[Knowledge Post=2] |
-496 |
998 |
247 |
1 |
.619 |
-2,452 |
1,460 |
|
|
[Knowledge Post=3] |
0 |
0 |
. |
|||||
|
[Attitude Post=2] |
-1.112 |
.658 |
2,852 |
1 |
.091 |
-2,402 |
.179 |
|
|
[Attitude=3] |
0 |
- |
- |
0 |
||||
|
Link function: Logit |
||||||||
|
a.
This parameter is set to zero because it is
redundant |
||||||||
Source: 2023
Primary Research Data
Table 12 illustrates the impact
of the independent variable on the dependent variable. The p-value obtained for
the variables gender, age, education level, length of employment, respondent's
position, and length of service is more significant than 0.005. Based on
statistical analysis, it was determined that no factor had a substantial impact
on changes in decision-making competence, as indicated by the fishbone diagram.
The research findings of (Tazebew et al., 2023) indicate no correlation between the
sociodemographic features of participants, such as job experience, education
level, and age, and the level of involvement of nurse managers in
decision-making. This disparity may be attributed to variations in health policies,
diverse nurse manager activities, and professional ideals.
Parallel Lines Test
Table 13. Parallel Lines Test of
Evidence-Based Practice Training Intervention
�on Increasing Decision-Making Competence Using
Fishbone Diagram
|
-2 Log Likelihood |
Chi-Square |
df |
Sig. |
|
|
Null Hypothesis |
50.869 |
|
|
|
|
General |
50.869 |
.000 |
0 |
|
Source: 2023 Primary Research
Data
Table 13 displays the outcomes of the Parallel
Lines test for enhancing decision-making proficiency using Fishbone Diagrams,
with a value of -2 Log. Given that the likelihood of obtaining the same value,
precisely 50,869, is observed, it can be concluded that the model is deemed
suitable. The results indicate that training in evidence-based practice
positively impacts decision-making ability, specifically when employing
fishbone diagrams.
CONCLUSION
Based on the
results and discussions, this study identifies various factors that affect
village financial management, which are divided into internal and external
factors. Internal factors include the quality of human resources, especially
village officials and their knowledge of financial management or accounting,
which significantly affects the effectiveness of village financial management.
Transparency and accountability in village financial management also play an
important role. In addition, the level of community participation and
involvement in the village financial management process is another critical
factor. External factors that affect village financial management include
regulations and policies from the central and regional governments, which
greatly determine how village finances are managed. The economic and social
conditions of the village community also have a significant impact on village
financial management. In addition, the availability of technology and
infrastructure affects the ability of villages to manage finances effectively.
Based on the
findings of this study, it is recommended that the village government pay
attention to several things, namely improving the quality of human resources
through training and continuous education for village officials to improve
competence in financial management and accounting. Strengthening transparency
and accountability can be done by implementing systems and mechanisms that
increase transparency and accountability in village financial management, such
as the use of information technology and village financial information systems
(SISKEUDES). The implication of this study is the importance of synergy between
the village government, the community, and the central or regional government
in creating efficient, transparent, and accountable village financial
management. With comprehensive support, it is hoped that village financial
management can be more optimal, so that it can support sustainable village
development and improve the welfare of the village community as a whole.
REFERENCES
Alatawi,
M., Aljuhani, E., Alsufiany, F., Aleid, K., Rawah, R., Aljanabi, S., &
Banakhar, M. (2020). Barriers to implementing evidence-based practice in the
nursing profession: A literature review. American Journal of Nursing Science,
9(1), 35�42.
Briner,
R. B., Denyer, D., & Rousseau, D. M. (2009). Evidence-based management:
concept cleanup time? Academy of Management Perspectives, 23(4),
19�32.
Clarke,
V., Lehane, E., Mulcahy, H., & Cotter, P. (2021). Nurse practitioners�
implementation of evidence‐based practice into routine care: A scoping
review. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based Nursing, 18(3),
180�189.
Fonseca,
T. (2023). Health Care Organizations� Research Capacity and Culture�s Effect
on Nurses� Evidence-Based Practice Implementation. Walden University.
Hidayat,
W., Yusuf, S., Erika, K. A., Kadar, K., & Juhelnita, J. (2019). Pendidikan
evidence-based practice melalui mentoring program oleh perawat di rumah sakit:
A literature review. Jurnal Keperawatan Muhammadiyah, 4(2).
Iswan.
(2021). Manajemen Pendidikan dan Pelatihan. Rajawali Press.
Jankelov�,
N., Joniakov�, Z., Bl�t�kov�, J., Skorkov�, Z., & Proch�zkov�, K. (2021).
Leading employees through the crises: Key competencies of crises management in
healthcare facilities in coronavirus pandemic. Risk Management and
Healthcare Policy, 561�573.
Koota,
E., K��ri�inen, M., Kyng�s, H., L��peri, M., & Melender, H. (2021).
Effectiveness of evidence‐based practice (ebp) education on emergency
nurses� ebp attitudes, knowledge, self‐efficacy, skills, and behavior: A
randomized controlled trial. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based Nursing,
18(1), 23�32.
Marquis,
B. L., & Huston, C. J. (2015). Leadership roles and management functions
in nursing: Theory and application. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
McNee,
P. (2020). Context of care and service delivery. Nursing Care of Children
and Young People with Long‐Term Conditions, 31�54.
Melnyk,
B. M., Fineout‐Overholt, E., & Mays, M. Z. (2008). The
evidence‐based practice beliefs and implementation scales: Psychometric
properties of two new instruments. Worldviews on Evidence‐Based
Nursing, 5(4), 208�216.
Moussata,
C. O. (2017). Evidence-based management and its influence on the practices
of senior leaders of hospitals in the Denver Metropolitan Area. Colorado
Technical University.
Oktiayuliandri.
(2015). Knowledge and Attitude of Nurses in Implementing Evidence-Based
Nursing Practice in Inpatient Room RSUP Dr.M.Djamil Padang.
Pishgooie,
A. H., Atashzadeh‐Shoorideh, F., Falc�‐Pegueroles, A., & Lotfi,
Z. (2019). Correlation between nursing managers� leadership styles and nurses�
job stress and anticipated turnover. Journal of Nursing Management, 27(3),
527�534.
Rahayu,
S., & Fajarini, M. (2020). Edukasi, Pelatihan Evidence-Based Practice In
Nursing, dan Evaluasi Pelaksanaan 7 (Tujuh) Benar Pemberian Obat. Jurnal
Abdimas Kesehatan (JAK), 2(1), 44�49.
Rustika,
S. S. (2013). Buku ajar metodologi riset keperawatan. Jakarta: CV. Trans
Info Media.
Saunders,
H., & Vehvil�inen-Julkunen, K. (2016). The state of readiness for
evidence-based practice among nurses: An integrative review. International
Journal of Nursing Studies, 56, 128�140.
Sudjiati,
E., Handiyani, H., Yetti, K., & Suryani, C. T. (2021). Optimalisasi Perawat
Sehat dalam Memberikan Pelayanan Keperawatan Bermutu. Journal of Telenursing
(JOTING), 3(1), 145�154.
Tazebew,
C., Mulugeta, T., & Boka, A. (2023). Nurse Managers� Involvement in
Decision-Making and Associated Factors in Selected Government Hospitals, Addis
Ababa, Ethiopia: A Cross-Sectional Study. SAGE Open Nursing, 9,
23779608231157990.
Umalihayati,
S., Km, S., Sutaguna, I. N. T., Par, S. S. T., Par, M., Zed, E. Z., Se, M. M.,
Kartika, R. A. S., Se, M. M., & Paramarta, W. A. (2023). Pengantar Ilmu
Manajemen. Cendikia Mulia Mandiri.
Upton,
D., & Upton, P. (2006). Development of an evidence‐based practice
questionnaire for nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 53(4),
454�458.
Wibowo.
(2016). Manajemen Kinerja, Edisi Kelima. Raja Grafindo Persada.
Wilkinson,
J. E., Nutley, S. M., & Davies, H. T. O. (2011). An exploration of the
roles of nurse managers in evidence‐based practice implementation. Worldviews
on Evidence‐Based Nursing, 8(4), 236�246.